There have been too many threads about which version is better. In short the two games are identical with a few differences in terms of catchable pokemons so that there is no better game, it's just a matter of personal preference.
Diamond Exclusive Pokemons
- #86: Seel
- #87: Dewgong
- #123: Scyther
- #198: Murkrow
- #212: Scizor
- #246: Larvitar
- #247: Pupitar
- #248: Tyranitar
- #261: Poochyena
- #262: Mightyena
- #304: Aron
- #305: Lairon
- #306: Aggron
- #352: Kecleon
- #408: Cranidos
- #409: Rampardos
- #430: Honchkrow
- #434: Stunky
- #435: Skuntank
- #483: Dialga
- #79: Slowpoke
- #80: Slowbro
- #127: Pinsir
- #199: Slowking
- #200: Misdreavus
- #228: Houndour
- #229: Houndoom
- #234: Stantler
- #363: Spheal
- #364: Sealeo
- #365: Walrein
- #371: Bagon
- #372: Shelgon
- #373: Salamence
- #410: Sheildon
- #411: Bastiodon
- #429: Mismagius
- #431: Glameow
- #432: Purugly
- #484: Palkia
http://www.gamefaqs.com/portable/ds/file/925602/48103
Please vote for your favourite game based on the differences mentioned above. If you intend to reply, make sure to provide a solid reason to your choice or points will be removed. Especially posts like "I choose Diamond" or "Diamond because Dialga is cooler" should be avoided for your own good. And don't discuss anything else! General discussions and emulation related questions have their respective threads (read the announcement).
-----------------------------
Note: I closed all previous Diamond vs Pearl for they all lack basis for comparison and were just posting for GPs purposes.
Edited by Channel28, 15 May 2012 - 11:40 AM.
![http://i17.photobuck...obocontest.png]](http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b94/YourClone/My%20Sigs/customrobocontest.png]){kind=link}