386 replies to this topic

[Kiknoamaru]

Twilight Princess by Graphics, Gameplay, and Innovation. Windwaker had plot/story line going for it, but Twilight Princess was always better.

[kyllar]

Twillight Princess is challenging...Wind Waker Sucks... it's easy and waaaaaaay too long.

[Aqua19]

Both are awesome games. Twilight Princess does have awesome graphics, but I'll still always prefer WW graphics. Looks aside, both had great stories, and a lot to do. TP wasn't very hard, but not very easy with it's few, but not overly complicated dungeons (Don't say anything. If you say the dungeons were easy, don't say anything. If they took you less than a day to get through, then good for you for having no life ).Getting from place to place in WW was fun at first though, but later seems to become a chore (Like, for example: If I'm going from Outset to Windfall, in one direction, it'll usually take about 5 minutes to get there, and I'll be doing something else to pass the time, provided that nothing happens... Unless of course you warp ). Then in TP we've got Epona back, whom was made elementary in Ocarina of Time.Storywise, WW was rather lighthearted, and tried to appeal to younger audiences with its cartoony feel. And it new when to get serious but stay lighthearted enough to keep younger kids playing too.TP has a darker story, with a (forgive me for comparing)Castlevania-"ish" feel to it. It will have its humor from time to time, but most of the time, the lightheartedness of the game gets defeated when in the Twilight World (But that's not the case if you're mildly attracted to Midna )All in all, if I want a more lighthearted experience, and if I feel like playing a cartoon, I'll play Wind Waker (Hmm... I wonder if Link ever accidentally grabbed Spongebob or Patrick with his Grappling hook under water?)For a slightly more serious story, but better gameplay, I'd play Twilight Princess.